The Miami Dolphins made a bold and controversial statement in the first round of the 2026 NFL Draft, selecting offensive lineman Kadyn Proctor and cornerback Chris Johnson in a series of trades that reshaped their roster and draft capital, leaving analysts and fans split on the team’s direction. General Manager Chris Grier and new offensive line coach John Eric Sullivan, known as Sully, executed a calculated but risky strategy that prioritized size and youth over immediate star power, passing on top-tier safety Caleb Downs and edge rusher Ruben Bane to land their targets. The moves, which included a trade down from pick 11 to 12 and a trade up from 30 to 27, have drawn sharp criticism for the Proctor selection while earning praise for the Johnson pick, setting the stage for a pivotal Day 2 of the draft.
The Dolphins entered the night with two first-round selections, holding the 11th and 30th overall picks, but they wasted no time in shaking up the board. At pick 11, Miami struck a deal with the Dallas Cowboys, moving back just one spot to 12 and acquiring two late fifth-round picks, numbers 177 and 180, in the process. With the 12th pick, they selected Kadyn Proctor, a massive offensive lineman from Alabama who measures in at 6-foot-7 and 352 pounds, matching the size of Miami’s 2024 second-round pick, Patrick Paul. Sully, in his post-draft press conference, made it clear that Proctor was his guy all along, stating that even if the Dolphins had stayed at 11, they would have taken Proctor over Downs or Bane. “When he walks out there, he’s going to change the tone of this offensive line in practice,” Sully said. “The ability to move large men will speak for itself.”
Proctor, just 20 years old, is viewed as a versatile lineman capable of playing guard or tackle, with Sully describing him as a “unique, rare 350-pound man who can play four spots on the offensive line.” The comparison to former Packers and Lions tackle Mekhi Becton has been floated, given Proctor’s blend of size, athleticism, and youth. However, the decision to pass on Downs, a dynamic safety from Ohio State who was widely considered a top-10 talent, and Bane, a explosive edge rusher from Miami, has sparked intense debate. Many draft analysts, including the host of the video, graded the Proctor pick as a D+, citing the opportunity cost of bypassing two players who could have filled immediate needs in the secondary and pass rush. “I would have taken Downs over Proctor a hundred times in a row,” the host said. “Every time I would have done it, I wouldn’t have had a second of hesitation.”
Despite the criticism, Sully’s philosophy of prioritizing size and toughness in cold-weather games was a driving factor. He has repeatedly emphasized that “fast gets slow, but big doesn’t get small,” a mantra that aligns with Proctor’s ability to anchor against powerful defensive lines. The Dolphins, who struggled in short-yardage situations last season, are betting that Proctor will help them win battles in December and January, particularly against division rivals like the Buffalo Bills. Proctor’s athletic testing, including a 5.2-second 40-yard dash and a 30-inch vertical, ranks among the best for offensive linemen his size, and his college tape shows a mauler in the run game who can also hold his own in pass protection.

The Dolphins’ second first-round pick came at 27, where they moved up three spots from 30 in a trade with the San Francisco 49ers. The deal cost Miami pick 90, a third-round selection, but they received pick 27 and moved down 48 spots in the fourth round, from pick 138 to 186. The net effect was a shift in value that analysts equated to acquiring a fourth-round pick, while the Dolphins kept their three third-round picks intact. With the 27th pick, Miami selected Chris Johnson, a cornerback from San Diego State who is 21 years old and measured at 6-foot-1 with 4.44-second speed in the 40-yard dash. Johnson’s athletic profile includes a 38-inch vertical and a 10-foot-8 broad jump, making him one of the most explosive defensive backs in the draft.
The Johnson pick was met with far more enthusiasm, earning an A-minus grade from the host. Johnson is projected as an immediate starter on the outside, competing with a crowded cornerback room that includes Derell Baker, Juju Brent, Alex Austin, Storm Duck, and Jason Marshall Jr. His college tape shows a lockdown corner who excels in man coverage, staying in phase with receivers and making plays on the ball. He recorded four interceptions last season, two of which he returned for touchdowns, and his ability to play nickel or safety adds versatility. Sully praised Johnson’s relentless style, saying, “He’s non-stop. Defensive coordinator Jeff Hafley told him he’s a polished player.” The host noted that Johnson was ranked 22nd on their big board and 18th on their Dolphins-specific board, making him excellent value at 27.
The trade-down for Proctor and the trade-up for Johnson resulted in the Dolphins acquiring two extra fifth-round picks, giving them a total of 11 selections heading into Day 2. The draft capital now includes picks 43, 75, 87, and 94 on Day 2, along with two fourth-rounders, three fifth-rounders, and two seventh-rounders. The host calculated that the net value of the trades was equivalent to a fourth-round pick, meaning Miami effectively added a free pick while landing their two targeted players. “Not happy with Proctor over Downs and Bane, but I’m cool with Proctor because his upside is really high,” the host said. “Happy with Johnson and happy the Dolphins acquired some extra draft capital.”

The overall grade for the Dolphins’ first round was a C-plus, reflecting the mixed reactions. The Proctor pick dragged down the average, while the Johnson pick and the trade value provided a boost. The host emphasized that the grade could improve if Proctor develops into a Pro Bowl-caliber lineman, but the immediate sting of passing on Downs and Bane is hard to ignore. “I’m giving Proctor a D-plus, Johnson an A-minus, and the trades a B,” the host said. “That averages out to a C-plus. It’s fair, but it’s not a home run.”
Looking ahead to Day 2, the Dolphins have several needs to address, including edge rusher, wide receiver, and safety. The host identified four top targets for pick 43: Missouri edge rusher Zion Young, Illinois edge rusher Gabe Jacas, Alabama wide receiver Jeremy Bernard, and safety Emanuel McNeil Warren. Young, in particular, was highlighted as a player the host would have been comfortable taking in the first round, citing his athleticism and physicality. “If Emanuel McNeil Warren is there at 43, he is number one on my board,” the host said. “Zion Young is right there too. I’m a big fan of his makeup.”
The Dolphins are also expected to consider wide receivers like Denzel Boston, though the host expressed skepticism about his fit. “I don’t like Denzel Boston in the slightest, but it’d be hard to argue the value at 43 is good enough,” the host said. Other potential targets include cornerbacks and offensive linemen, but the focus remains on adding playmakers to a roster that already features quarterback Tua Tagovailoa, wide receiver Tyreek Hill, and a revamped offensive line.

The video also included a sponsored segment for Prize Picks, the daily fantasy sports app, which the host used to discuss the NBA playoffs and other sports. The host encouraged viewers to use code HMA for a $50 bonus after playing their first $5 lineup. “Playoff basketball is rolling on, and it’s fun to cash in on the action,” the host said. “Follow me on Prize Picks, my username is Rolley CS. Hopefully you didn’t follow this entry because it was a stinker.”
The Dolphins’ draft strategy under Sully and Grier has been defined by a commitment to size, youth, and versatility, but the first-round results have left the fanbase divided. Proctor’s selection signals a long-term investment in the trenches, while Johnson’s addition addresses a secondary that struggled with consistency last season. The trades also set up a deep Day 2 where Miami can target high-upside players at positions of need. The host concluded by urging viewers to subscribe for more coverage, including a Day 2 mock draft and live reactions to the second and third rounds.
As the draft continues, the Dolphins will look to build on a night that saw them add two potential starters and extra picks, but the shadow of passing on Downs and Bane will linger until Proctor proves his worth. For now, the grade is a C-plus, with the potential to rise or fall based on how the rest of the draft unfolds. The NFL world will be watching closely as Miami aims to turn its first-round gambles into a winning formula for the 2026 season and beyond.